TV Shows Heartland

Amber Marshall on Real-Life Loss and Giving Amy Another Chance at Love

The Heartland star opens up about healing on and off screen.

Heartland Amy and Jack

Ty’s death, a co-star lost far too young, and a new proposal she still hasn’t answered. Amber Marshall has spent six seasons playing grief and the slow way back from it.

When Amber Marshall married Shawn Turner on their own farm in the summer of 2013, one guest was working. Heather Conkie, then the showrunner of Heartland, was there taking notes.

“I said, ‘Oh, we’re bound to see this on the screen in a year or so,'” Marshall said when she told TV Insider about it in 2023. “Sure enough, very similar stories took place.” Amy and Ty got married in the Season 8 finale in 2015. You can read more about Amber’s real ranch wedding here.

Advertisement

That’s how it has gone for her for almost two decades. Her life and Amy’s keep running into each other. Usually that’s the charm of the show. A few seasons ago, it got heavy.

Here’s where things stand. Amber Marshall is 38. She was 19 when she started playing Amy Fleming. Heartland Season 20 premiered on CBC on October 4, 2026, and the show is now past 280 episodes.

The phone call before Ty’s death

The first loss happened off camera, about two years before fans saw it. Graham Wardle called Marshall to tell her he was leaving the show, and she heard it before the producers did.

“He wanted to let me know before he told anybody else,” she told the Calgary Herald in January 2021. “And I was hurt. When he first told me, it stung a little bit. But then, as I had time to process it, I understood it.”

She kept the secret. Then on January 10, 2021, the Season 14 premiere aired. Within minutes Ty collapsed and died from complications of the gunshot wound he took at the end of Season 13. The story jumped ahead a year. Wardle has explained his reasons since, and we’ve covered why Graham Wardle left Heartland separately.

To play a young widow, Marshall went to someone who had lived it. A friend of hers had lost her husband young, in a sudden accident, after more than ten years together. Marshall didn’t want to reopen that wound, so she mostly talked to the friend’s sister. She learned that the whole first year had been a daze.

That’s the Amy viewers met in Season 14. “It’s been a year of numbness,” Marshall said. “It’s been a year of her crying until she can’t cry anymore.”

What playing a grieving widow cost her

On screen it was Amy’s grief. On set it was Marshall’s job, day after day.

“For myself, playing a grieving widow was hard on me,” she told TV Insider. “Every day you’re coming in upset and trying to get into very dark places.”

She called those seasons “really taxing.” The writers didn’t hurry Amy through it either. “There were a few seasons we wanted to spend honoring his legacy,” she said. It took until Season 16 for the show to decide that “Amy is allowed to move forward. She is allowed to be happy.”

Real life helped her with that part too. She remembered a friend who lost her husband and used to joke about the man next door. “Four years later she ended up married her neighbor,” Marshall said. People do find love again. It just doesn’t come on a schedule.

Advertisement

Losing Robert Cormier

One of the first men to catch Amy’s eye after Ty was Finn Cotter, a farrier and Al’s grandson, who showed up in Season 15. He was played by Toronto actor Robert Cormier, and fans were excited to see Amy falling for someone again.

So did the people making the show. “We spent multiple days having all kinds of different story arc talks,” Marshall said. “We thought, ‘Okay, this is going to take us through the rest of the season and beyond.'” She described Cormier as “such a great guy and so open and very honest to work with.”

Cormier died on September 23, 2022, at 33. His sister said he died in hospital from injuries he suffered in a fall. Season 16 premiered on CBC nine days later.

“When we found out the news, it was devastating,” Marshall said. “It was one of those moments that served as a reminder that you never know when you’re going to lose someone around you.” She also thinks it pulled the cast closer: “You can’t take anything for granted.”

Finn’s story wrapped up quietly in Season 16. He left to help a friend’s family in Saskatchewan and didn’t come back. For Amy it was another door that closed. For the cast it was a real goodbye.

Nathan, and a proposal still waiting

Then came Nathan Pryce Jr., played by Spencer Lord. He arrived in Season 17 as the rival rancher next door, which is not usually how a Heartland romance starts. Over Season 18 he and Amy got close, and in Season 19 Amy admitted that her distance with him came from things that reminded her of Ty.

Season 19 ended with Nathan selling his ranch, planning a move to Salt Spring Island and proposing. Amy smiled. She didn’t answer.

The Season 20 premiere, “Renewal,” shows why. “I’m not saying no,” Amy tells him. Her problem is that he made huge decisions without her. When the island deal falls apart, she suggests he buy into Heartland Beef. He turns her down. “I still have my pride,” he says. He wants to have something to offer her and Lyndy.

So Nathan goes out on the working cow horse circuit and promises to propose again, with a ring this time and down on one knee. “I’m gonna hold you to that,” Amy says. Later she breaks down in front of Lou and asks how long the two of them can keep living apart. Lyndy now gets a chapter of a book from Nathan over the phone every night.

For a character who spent years inside grief, it’s a familiar kind of hurt. This time the man is still there. He’s just far away. Our look at Amy’s answer to Nathan covers how the proposal was set up. US viewers can catch up when Season 20 reaches UP Faith & Family on November 19.

The life she goes home to

When filming wraps for the day, Marshall goes home to a ranch just outside Calgary that she shares with her husband, Shawn Turner. There are horses and cows, and she fosters dogs through the Foothills Animal Support Society, which she runs.

That overlap with Amy works in both directions. Marshall has said that when a storyline reaches something she’s been through herself, she can draw on it. “Wow, I’ve been there and experienced this,” is how she put it. “I know exactly how I handled it emotionally and can bring that into my character.”

Advertisement

Viewers have told her the show did something similar for them. In an interview with CBC News as Season 20 began, she said some fans told her Heartland helped them through hard times. Asked how much longer she wants to keep going, she said, “Oh gosh, another 20.” Then she went further. “I’ll do Heartland till I die,” she said. We dug into what she meant by that in an earlier piece.

She moved to Alberta during Season 2 and doesn’t plan to leave. “I can never see myself relocating again,” she said. “This is home for me.”

Twenty seasons in, Amy has a daughter who’s growing up fast, a man who wants to marry her and a question she hasn’t answered. After everything she has carried on screen, Marshall seems glad to let her take her time. For more on how this whole story started, see Ty and Amy’s love story.

All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Opinions belong to readers.

All comments (26)
Sort:
  1. April Martin •

    I think you should take it easy for a while and worry about your daughter and your job. Also worry about your grandpa and your family.

    Reply
  2. Kari Eddy •

    Love again

    Reply
  3. Aaron •

    My opinion is Amy should take care of her daughter and the horses.cause if Ty was supposed to her soulmate and it took almost 9 years for them to get married on the show then it’s way to soon for another love interest. I want Ty back on the show and are story lines to tell for him to come back.

    Reply
  4. Sheila Stuckless •

    I like Nathan. They have both been through a lot and can’t help each other while helping themselves and other family members.

    Reply
  5. Janice H. •

    I hope Amy finds love again, everyone deserves to move forward and be happy even while grieving.

    Reply
  6. Juie •

    Ty needs to come back. He and Amy were good together.

    Reply
  7. Billy Lee •

    The first 14 seasons was as good as any show I have ever watched. I still watch it here in Texas when we get it but it isn’t quiet as good. Don’t get me wrong I still watch it and enjoy the heck out of it.

    Reply